Same Sex Marriage

Topics: Same-sex marriage, Marriage, Homosexuality Pages: 11 (4390 words) Published: March 16, 2005
Matthew Brigham
Legal Direct Study
Final Copy
December 17, 2004

The proposed legalization of same-sex marriage is one of the most significant issues in current American family law. Right now it is one of the most strongly advocated reforms discussed in law reviews, one of the most explosive political questions facing lawmakers, and one of the most provocative issues emerging before American courts. If same-sex marriage is legalized, it could be one of the most revolutionary policy decisions in the history of American family law. Supporting Side

The potential consequences, positive or negative, for children, parents, same-sex couples, families, social structure, public health, and the status of women are huge. Given the importance of the issue, the value of broad debate of the reasons for and against legalizing same-sex marriage should be obvious. Marriage is much more than merely a commitment to love one another. Aside from public and religious beliefs, marriage entails legally imposed financial responsibility and legally authorized financial benefits. Marriage provides automatic legal protections for the spouse, including medical visitation, succession of a deceased spouse's property, as well as pension and other rights. Marriage has changed throughout the years. In Western law, wives are now equal rather than subordinate partners; interracial marriage is now widely accepted, both in law and in society; and marital failure itself, rather than the fault of one partner, may be grounds for a divorce. Societal change have been felt in marriages over the past 25 years as divorce rates have increased and have been integrated into even upper class families. Proposals to legalize same-sex marriage or to enact broad domestic partnership laws are currently being promoted by gay and lesbian activists, especially in Europe and North America. The trend in western European nations during the past decade has been to increase legal aid to homosexual relations and has included marriage benefits to some same-sex couples. For example, within the past six years, three Scandinavian countries have enacted domestic partnership laws allowing same-sex couples in which at least one partner is a citizen of the specified country therefore allowing many benefits that heterosexual marriages are given. In the Netherlands, the Parliament is considering domestic partnership status for same-sex couples, all major political parties favor recognizing same-sex relations, and more than a dozen towns have already done so. Finland provides governmental social benefits to same-sex partners. Belgium allows gay prisoners the right to have conjugal visits from same-sex partners. An overwhelming majority of European nations have granted partial legal status to homosexual relationships. The European Parliament also has passed a resolution calling for equal rights for gays and lesbians. In the United States, efforts to legalize same-sex domestic partnership have had some, limited success. The Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, Inc. reported that by mid-1995, thirty-six municipalities, eight counties, three states, five state agencies, and two federal agencies extended some benefits to, or registered for some official purposes, same-sex domestic partnerships. In 1994, the California legislature passed a domestic partnership bill that provided official state registration of same-sex couples and provided limited marital rights and privileges relating to hospital visitation, wills and estates, and powers of attorney. While at the time California's Governor Wilson eventually vetoed the bill, its passage by the legislature represented a notable political achievement for advocates of same-sex marriage. The most significant prospects for legalizing same-sex marriage in the near future are in Hawaii, where advocates of same-sex marriage have won a major judicial victory that could lead to...

Cited: Article IV, sec.1 United States Constitution
Baehr v.Miike, 910 P.2d 112 (Hawaii Jan 23, 1996)
Baehr v. Lewin, 852 P.2d 44, (Hawaii May 5, 1993)
"Gay marriages should be allowed, state judge rules," The Wall Street Journal, Dec
"Hawaii judge ends gay marriage ban," New York Times, Dec. 4, 1996
"Hawaii ruling lifts ban on marriage of same-sex couples" Los Angeles Times
"Announcing same-sex unions," The Boston Globe, Page 15A, Dec. 2, 1996
Bonauto, "Advising non-traditional families: A general introduction," OCT B
Cox, Barbara "Same sex marriage and choice of law", 1994 Wisconsin Law Review.
Reidinger, Paul, American Bar Association Journal, Oct 1996
Stoddard, Thomas, "Gay marriages: Make them legal", Current Issues and Enduring Questions, Bedford Books, Boston, 1996
Why Marriage Matters: Twenty-One Conclusions from the Social Sciences (New York: Institute for American Values, 2002); see
Linda J
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Same Sex Marriage Essay
  • Gay Marriage... Legalize It? Essay
  • Same Sex Marriage Essay
  • Essay about Same-Sex Marriages
  • Same-sex Marriage and Jordan Essay
  • Same-Sex Marriage Essay
  • Legalizing Same Sex Marriage Essay
  • Same-Sex Marriage

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free
The Platinum Collection Greatest Hits I II III | Хищник / The Predator (2018) WEB-DLRip | Локализованная версия | D | Adventure